Trust defined as – The ability to rely upon others to be truthful and to do as they say, and to follow established rules, procedures and custom and practice.
Can a hierarchical organization with Manager / Subordinate relationships increase and attract trust? Can individuals be free in a system like this? Are justice, fairness and equity false assumptions within hierarchies? Isn’t authority the same as authoritarianism and autocracy; which repel trust for the sake of those in power?
Wouldn’t we all be more trusting if these organizations toppled we had NO MANAGEMENT / SUBORDINATE relationships and allowed individuals the ability to organize their own work, rewards, punishment, rules and procedures?
“Liberty and freedom are conditions of individuals living and working together in social systems that are organized to provide for the trust and justice required for effective interpersonal dealings. The achievement of liberty, freedom, trust and justice, therefore depends on the design of our social institutions.” –Elliot Jaques
The workplace has the capacity to develop Attract or Repel Trust. Psychologically when aroused either mechanism in people readily takes over. They magnify and distort the reality that is separate from our perception and experience.
Trust Attracting Organizations
Process heavily influenced by trust and acceptance
Trust Repelling Organizations
Process heavily influenced by anxiety or fear.
– Equal and felt fairness between personal capability to complete great work, current work and compensation.
– Recognition is given appropriately
– Correct distance in knowledge, responsibility, competency between manager and employee.
– Managers are seen as competent and are held accountable for the output of employees.
– Managers are involved in adding value and increasing the ability to make decisions and use judgment of employees.
– Clearly defined accountabilities and structures of how work gets done, who has authority to do what, and what processes should be used for the completion of work.
– Openness of information, and what is happening within the organization.
– Unequal gap between personal capability to complete great work, current work and compensation.
– Excessive bureaucracy and top heavy management structure (too many levels within the organization)
– Absent or non-existent relationship of managers and employees.
– Employees often have no clear understanding of who their manager is.
– Employees often lack clear understanding of what their manager is accountable for.
– Lack of honest sharing of information.
– Instability in what is expected for great work and the path to achieve great work.
– Excessive “Reverse Peter Principal” abuse. Tasks delegated too low in the hierarchy; creating a scape-goat mentality of accountability.
Now Your Turn;
Which of the above sounds most like your workplace? If things were more on the ‘Trust Attracting’ side how would you know? How would you manager know? How would your peers know? How would you treat your workmates different once the Trust-Attraction increases?
What is your opinion on Hierarchies and Jaques idea that ‘liberty and freedom, trust’ stem from our social institutions?
image by Ella’s Dad